Is this funny? I read it in a tweet and I must admit, I laughed., Mostly in shock, but I still laughed. "Are you an angel that fell from heaven? Because you were unconscious when I was raping you" The message is horrible and the joke is at the expense of the victim, but the contrast between the two lines got me. What do you think?
And before I go -- we're retiring for the holidays, next chat on January 7 -- I will answer this question.
I think this fails the first test of edgy humor, so nothing else matters and we needn't even engage the issue of taste. It's not objectively funny enough, because it's internally weak. I get the colossal clash of opposite tones, but that doesn't really make up for odd logic: Why would a fallen angel be unconscious, or, rather, why would an unconscious person be likely to be a fallen angel? It is missing a step. Yes, I am being very literal, but humor is a harsh taskmaster.
Having failed question one, all else is moot.